Replacing a gas fireplace insert updates the look of your room and can improve heating efficiency. This guide covers removing the old unit and installing a new one. Before you start, confirm the new insert matches your existing gas line type (natural gas or propane) and venting system. If you are not fully comfortable working with gas, hire a licensed professional.
What You’ll Need
- New gas insert (sized to fit your fireplace opening)
- Adjustable wrench and pipe wrench
- Screwdrivers (flathead and Phillips)
- Socket set
- Pipe thread sealant rated for gas
- Soapy water in a spray bottle (for leak testing)
- Flashlight
- Work gloves and safety glasses
- Drop cloth or old sheet
Step-by-Step
- Turn off the gas supply. Locate the shutoff valve on the gas line feeding the insert. It is usually a lever or knob on the line near the fireplace. Turn it so the handle is perpendicular to the pipe. Also turn off the gas at the main supply if you prefer extra safety.
- Disconnect the old insert. Remove the front panel or glass door (often held by screws or clips). Inside, you will see the gas line connection and possibly an electrical cord for the blower or ignition. Unplug any electrical connections. Use a wrench to disconnect the gas line at the union or fitting. Be careful—some gas may remain in the line, so have a rag handy to catch drips.
- Remove the old unit. Slide the insert out of the fireplace opening. It may be heavy, so have a helper support it. Place it on a drop cloth. If it is secured with screws or brackets, remove those first.
- Inspect the fireplace and vent. Check the firebox and chimney for debris, soot, or damage. If you have a vented insert, ensure the vent pipe is clear and in good condition. For a vent-free insert, confirm the opening is clean and the gas line is intact.
- Prepare the new insert. Read the manufacturer’s instructions thoroughly. Check that the new insert fits the opening—measure the height, width, and depth. If it is too big, you may need to enlarge the opening (a job for a professional). If it is smaller, you can use non-combustible filler panels.
- Position the new insert. Slide the new insert into the fireplace opening. Make sure it is centered and level. Most inserts have adjustable legs or leveling screws at the base. Use a level to check both side-to-side and front-to-back.
- Connect the gas line. Apply pipe thread sealant to the male threads of the gas line (or use the fitting provided with the insert). Tighten the connection with two wrenches—one to hold the fitting, the other to turn the nut. Do not overtighten; hand-tight plus a quarter turn with the wrench is usually enough.
- Reconnect electrical components. If your insert has a blower or electronic ignition, plug in the power cord or reconnect the wires according to the manual. Ensure the cord is not pinched.
- Check for gas leaks. Turn on the gas supply valve. Mix a small amount of dish soap with water in a spray bottle. Spray the gas line connections (including the shutoff valve) with the soapy water. If you see bubbles forming, there is a leak. Tighten the connection slightly and re-test. If bubbles persist, turn off the gas and call a professional.
- Test the insert. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions to light the pilot and ignite the burner. Watch for a steady blue flame. If the flame is yellow or flickers, adjust the air shutter (if available) or consult the manual.
- Reinstall the front panel and glass. Once the insert is working and no leaks are present, reattach the glass door and front panel. Make sure all screws are tight.
- Final inspection. Run the insert for a few minutes to ensure it heats properly and there are no unusual odors (a slight smell on first use is normal as dust burns off). Check that the blower (if any) operates correctly.
Common Mistakes
- Skipping the leak test. Even a tiny gas leak is dangerous. Always test with soapy water.
- Using the wrong sealant. Use only pipe thread sealant rated for gas, not standard plumber’s tape or glue.
- Overtightening fittings. This can crack the fitting or strip threads, leading to leaks.
- Ignoring clearances. Inserts need specific clearance to combustible materials. Check the manual and maintain proper distances.
- Not checking the vent. For vented inserts, a blocked vent can cause carbon monoxide buildup. Inspect and clean the vent before installing.
- Forgetting to turn off the gas. Always shut off the gas supply before disconnecting anything.
Tips
- Take photos of the old connections before disconnecting to help with reinstallation.
- Have a fire extinguisher nearby, just in case.
- If the old insert is heavy, use a dolly or have a second person help lift.
- Clean the glass with a recommended cleaner before first use to avoid baked-on residue.
- Keep the manual for the new insert in a safe place for future reference.
- Consider hiring a professional if your gas line needs modification or if you are unsure about any step.
Troubleshooting
Insert won’t light. Check that the gas supply is on and the pilot light is lit. If the pilot won’t stay lit, the thermocouple may be faulty—replace it. If the igniter sparks but no flame, check the gas line for blockages.
Gas smell. Immediately turn off the gas supply and ventilate the room. Do not operate any electrical switches or appliances. Call a professional to inspect the connections.
Flame is yellow or sooty. This indicates incomplete combustion. Adjust the air shutter (if available) to allow more air. If the problem persists, the burner or gas pressure may be incorrect—consult a technician.
Blower doesn’t work. Check the power cord and outlet. Ensure the blower switch is on. If it still doesn’t run, the motor may be defective—contact the manufacturer.
Insert is not heating well. Ensure the vent is clear and the glass is clean. Check that the fireplace damper is open (if applicable). If the insert is too small for the room, it may not heat effectively.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I install a gas insert myself? Yes, if you are comfortable with gas connections and follow all safety steps. However, many local codes require a licensed professional for gas work—check your local regulations.
How long does a gas insert last? With proper maintenance, a gas insert can last for many years—often over a decade. Regular cleaning and annual inspections help extend its life.
Do I need a chimney for a gas insert? It depends on the type. Vented inserts require a functioning chimney or vent pipe. Vent-free inserts do not, but they are not allowed in all areas—check local codes.
Can I convert my insert from natural gas to propane? Some models have conversion kits, but it is not a simple DIY job. It requires changing the burner orifice and adjusting the gas pressure. Always have a professional do the conversion.
Why does my insert smell on first use? New inserts have oils and dust from manufacturing that burn off during the first few uses. This is normal and should dissipate after a few hours of operation.
How often should I service my gas insert? Have it inspected annually by a qualified technician. Clean the glass and check for leaks regularly.