Choosing the right gym membership can make a significant difference in your fitness journey. Two of the most popular gym chains—Anytime Fitness and Planet Fitness—offer distinct experiences, pricing structures, and amenities. This guide will help you compare Anytime Fitness vs Planet Fitness membership options step by step, so you can make an informed decision that fits your goals, lifestyle, and budget.
What You’ll Need
- Access to the official websites of Anytime Fitness and Planet Fitness
- Basic understanding of your fitness goals and schedule
- Awareness of your preferred gym locations or commute
- Notebook or digital app to jot down comparisons
- Contact information for local gym branches (optional, for follow-up questions)
Step-by-Step
- Clarify Your Fitness Priorities
Before comparing memberships, identify your top priorities: Do you want 24/7 access? Are group classes or personal training important? How far are you willing to travel? Knowing what matters most will help you focus on the features that impact your decision. - Locate Nearby Branches
Visit the location finder tools on the Anytime Fitness and Planet Fitness websites. Enter your zip code or city to find gyms close to your home, work, or school. Note each gym’s exact location, parking situation, and public transit options if relevant. - Check Access Hours and Policies
Anytime Fitness locations generally offer 24/7 access to members, including on holidays. Planet Fitness hours vary by location—some are open 24/7, others have limited hours (often closing overnight or on certain days). Confirm the opening hours for your preferred branches. - Compare Membership Costs and Fees
Visit each gym’s website or call your local branches to check current membership costs. Both chains often run promotions, so rates may change. Key factors to compare:- Monthly dues
- Annual or startup fees
- Commitment length (month-to-month vs. annual contract)
- Cancellation policies and fees
Write down the pricing details for each location you’re considering, as costs can vary by region.
- Review Amenities and Equipment
Make a list of amenities each gym offers. Consider:- Cardio and strength equipment variety
- Locker rooms and showers
- Group fitness classes (e.g., yoga, spin, HIIT; included or extra cost)
- Personal training options (and cost)
- Hydro-massage, tanning, or other extras
- Guest privileges (can you bring a friend?)
Planet Fitness is known for a “Judgement Free Zone” atmosphere and basics-focused setup, with premium “Black Card” amenities like massage chairs and tanning. Anytime Fitness locations are independently owned, so amenities and equipment can vary, but most offer a full range of cardio and strength machines and private showers.
- Assess Cleanliness and Atmosphere
If possible, schedule a tour or day pass at each gym. Note the cleanliness, crowd levels at your preferred workout times, staff friendliness, and overall vibe. Planet Fitness emphasizes a no-intimidation policy, while Anytime Fitness often feels smaller and more community-oriented. - Evaluate Access to Other Locations
Both chains offer reciprocal access, but policies differ. Anytime Fitness members can use any of their 4,000+ worldwide locations after 30 days of membership. Planet Fitness “Black Card” members can visit any location in the US (over 2,000 gyms), but standard members are limited to their home club. - Consider Additional Perks and Programs
Look for any extra benefits, such as mobile apps, fitness assessments, member challenges, or discounts on partner services. These extras may add value beyond basic gym access. - Read Recent Reviews
Search Google, Yelp, or local Facebook groups for recent member reviews of the specific locations you’re considering. Pay attention to comments about staff responsiveness, equipment maintenance, and billing issues. - Make Your Decision
Weigh the information you’ve gathered against your initial priorities. Consider visiting your top choice again to confirm your decision. When ready, sign up online or in person, and keep a copy of your contract and cancellation terms.
Common Mistakes
- Assuming all locations are the same: Both Anytime Fitness and Planet Fitness have franchised operations, so amenities, cleanliness, and service can vary widely between branches.
- Not asking about hidden fees: Both chains may charge enrollment, annual, or cancellation fees not clearly listed online. Always confirm the total cost before joining.
- Ignoring contract terms: Some memberships auto-renew or have early termination fees. Read all terms carefully before signing.
- Overlooking gym hours: Not all Planet Fitness locations are open 24/7, and some Anytime Fitness clubs may have restricted staffed hours for certain services.
- Skipping a gym visit: Photos and amenities lists don’t always reflect current conditions. A personal visit is the best way to assess a gym’s environment.
Tips
- Try before you buy: Ask for a free day pass or trial week. Most clubs offer these, especially if you ask in person.
- Time your signup: Gyms often run promotions near New Year, summer, or back-to-school seasons. Waiting for a deal can save you money.
- Negotiate fees: While not all clubs will negotiate, some franchise owners have flexibility on startup or annual fees—especially if you’re ready to commit.
- Ask about guest policies: If you plan to work out with friends or family, Planet Fitness Black Card is more guest-friendly than most Anytime Fitness memberships.
- Use the app features: Both gyms have mobile apps that can help you check gym hours, track workouts, or access virtual training content.
- Monitor your usage: If you find yourself not going regularly, revisit your membership choice or consider pay-as-you-go fitness options.
Troubleshooting
- Billing Issues: If you notice unexpected charges or have trouble canceling, contact your local club manager first. Follow up with written communication and request a confirmation of cancellation or fee adjustments. If unresolved, escalate to the corporate customer service department.
- Unmet Expectations: If amenities or hours differ from what was promised, bring up the issue with staff. Document your concerns and request clarification or compensation if you feel misled.
- Overcrowding: If your chosen gym is too crowded during your preferred times, ask staff for the best times to visit or consider changing locations if your membership allows.
- Equipment Maintenance: If machines are often out of service, report them to staff and track how quickly repairs are made. If issues persist, it may be worth considering another location.
- Access Problems: For Anytime Fitness, if your key fob doesn’t work or you have trouble accessing other locations, contact your home club for help. For Planet Fitness, Black Card members should confirm reciprocal access in advance, especially when traveling.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Which gym is cheaper: Anytime Fitness or Planet Fitness?
- Generally, Planet Fitness has lower monthly fees, especially with its basic membership. However, total costs can vary by location, promotions, and membership tier. Always compare your local clubs directly.
- Can I use any location with my membership?
- Anytime Fitness members can use any club worldwide after 30 days. Planet Fitness Black Card holders have nationwide access, while standard members are limited to their home club.
- Are classes included in the membership?
- At Planet Fitness, most classes are included with all memberships, though offerings are basic. At Anytime Fitness, classes may be included or require an additional fee, depending on the location.
- Is there a cancellation fee?
- Both gyms may charge cancellation fees, especially if you signed a 12-month contract. Review the contract terms and ask staff to explain cancellation policies before joining.
- Which gym is better for beginners?
- Planet Fitness is known for its welcoming, beginner-friendly atmosphere and basic equipment. Anytime Fitness also serves beginners but may suit those seeking more equipment variety or a quieter environment.
- Can I bring a guest with me?
- Planet Fitness Black Card holders can bring a guest each visit. Anytime Fitness guest policies vary by club; some allow guests during staffed hours, often for a fee or limited number of visits.
Related
- Best 4 Hour Crock Pot Recipes: Easy Comfort Meals Fast
- Greek Yogurt Bowl Ideas: 10 Delicious Ways to Upgrade Breakfast
- No Oil Zucchini Bread Recipe: Moist, Healthy & Easy
Anytime Fitness vs Planet Fitness: Key Differences in Membership