Using Old Shingles in the Garden: A Practical Guide

Replacing a roof leaves you with a stack of old asphalt shingles that most people haul to a landfill. Before you do, know that those worn-out shingles have several genuinely useful second lives in the garden. They are waterproof, durable, and already cut into manageable pieces, which makes them great for weed barriers, path edging, and protecting plant stems from harsh weather. This guide walks you through the safe, practical ways to put them to work, along with the important cautions about what you should not do with them.

What You’ll Need

  • Old asphalt shingles, cleaned of loose grit and debris
  • Heavy-duty utility knife or tin snips for cutting
  • Work gloves to protect your hands from sharp edges and embedded granules
  • Sturdy scissors for trimming landscape fabric, if you use it
  • Garden staples or long nails for securing shingles in place
  • Hammer or mallet
  • Measuring tape or a long straightedge
  • Safety glasses to keep granules out of your eyes

Step-by-Step

  1. Inspect and sort your shingles. Set aside any that are badly cracked, crumbling, or heavily covered in moss or algae. You want pieces that are still intact and flexible enough to handle without breaking. Shingles that are falling apart are not worth the effort.
  2. Clean off loose granules. Run a stiff brush over the surface or rinse them with a hose. Asphalt shingles shed their mineral granules as they age, and those loose bits will just make a mess in your garden beds. Let them dry completely before cutting.
  3. Decide on your primary use. The two most reliable options are a weed barrier under mulch or a path surface. For a weed barrier, you will lay the shingles flat on the soil. For a path, you will overlap them like roof tiles so water sheds off them.
  4. Prepare the area. Remove any existing weeds or grass from the spot where you plan to lay the shingles. Rake the soil smooth so the shingles lie flat without rocking. If you are making a path, dig down a couple of inches so the finished surface sits level with the surrounding ground.
  5. Cut shingles to fit. Score the shingle with a utility knife along a straightedge, then bend it along the score line to snap it. For curves or irregular shapes, use tin snips. Always cut on a solid surface like a piece of plywood, and cut away from your body.
  6. Lay the shingles. For a weed barrier, place them flat with the edges butted together, leaving no gaps. For a path, start at the bottom edge and work upward, overlapping each shingle over the one below it by a few inches, like a roof. This way, water runs off instead of pooling underneath.
  7. Secure the shingles. Drive a garden staple or a long nail through the shingle near each corner and into the soil below. For a path, put a fastener at each corner and one in the middle of the long edges. This keeps them from shifting in wind or heavy rain.
  8. Cover with mulch (for weed barriers). Spread a layer of wood chips, bark, or gravel over the shingles. The shingles block light and moisture from reaching weed seeds, and the mulch on top keeps the area looking natural. Aim for a mulch layer at least a couple of inches thick.
  9. Use shingles as plant protection. Lean a shingle against the base of a young tree or shrub to shield the trunk from string trimmers and mowers. You can also place a shingle over tender seedlings in early spring to keep frost off them overnight, removing it in the morning.
  10. Edge your beds with them. Stand shingles on their long edge and press them a few inches into the soil to create a low, tidy border between a lawn and a flower bed. Overlap the ends slightly and tap them down with a mallet.

Common Mistakes

  • Using shingles near edible crops. Old asphalt shingles contain petroleum-based compounds and may leach small amounts of chemicals into the soil over time. Do not use them as a mulch or barrier in vegetable beds, herb gardens, or anywhere you grow food. Stick to ornamental beds and paths.
  • Laying them directly over grass. If you skip the step of removing existing vegetation, the grass will push up through seams and make the surface lumpy. Always clear the area first.
  • Forgetting to secure them. An unsecured shingle will curl, slide, or blow away in the first strong wind. Fastening them down is not optional.
  • Cutting with a dull blade. A dull knife slips, which is how people end up cutting themselves. Replace the blade or use sharp tin snips.
  • Using shingles as a fire pit base. Asphalt shingles are flammable and will release toxic fumes if they catch fire. Never put them under or near a fire pit, grill, or any open flame.

Tips

  • Stack shingles flat in a dry place before you start. If they have been curled up, lay them in the sun for an hour; the warmth makes them more pliable and easier to work with.
  • For a path, lay a sheet of landscape fabric under the shingles first. It adds an extra layer of weed protection and keeps the soil from staining the underside of the shingles.
  • Use the darker, less weathered side of the shingle facing up. It looks more uniform and hides dirt better.
  • Save the cleanest, most intact shingles for visible areas like paths and edging. Use the beat-up ones under mulch where nobody will see them.
  • If you have a lot of shingles, consider building a small cold frame. Stack them to make low walls around a glass pane or clear plastic sheet for an easy season extender.
  • Wear a dust mask when cutting. The granules and asphalt dust are not something you want to breathe in.

Troubleshooting

  • Shingles keep curling up at the edges. This happens when they are laid on uneven ground or not secured tightly. Re-level the soil, then fasten each corner with a staple or nail driven flush. If a shingle is too warped to lie flat, cut it into smaller pieces and use those.
  • Weeds are coming up between the shingles. You left gaps or the seams are too wide. Pull the weeds, then either shift the shingles to close the gaps or lay a strip of landscape fabric over the seams before covering with mulch.
  • Water pools on top of the shingles. Your path has a low spot. Lift the affected shingles, add a little soil to raise the area, and re-lay them with a slight slope so water runs off to the side. For a barrier, just poke a few small drainage holes with a nail to let water through.
  • The shingles smell strongly of asphalt on hot days. This is normal for new or lightly aged shingles, but it fades after a few weeks in the sun. If the smell is overpowering, the shingles may be too fresh or of a type not meant for ground contact. Remove them and use a different material.
  • You run out of shingles halfway through the project. Mix in other flat, waterproof materials like old ceramic tiles, flagstone pieces, or heavy plastic sheeting as a temporary fill, then cover everything with mulch so the mix is not visible.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use old shingles in a vegetable garden? No. Asphalt shingles are petroleum-based and can leach chemicals into the soil, which is not safe for edible crops. Use them only in ornamental beds, paths, or as non-food plant protection.

Will shingles kill the grass underneath them? Yes, if laid flat and secured, they block light and moisture, which kills grass and weeds. That is exactly why they work as a weed barrier. Remove the dead vegetation before you mulch over them.

How long will old shingles last in the garden? Asphalt shingles are designed to withstand decades of weather on a roof, so in the garden they can last for many years. The main risk is UV damage from sun exposure, so covering them with mulch or placing them in shaded areas extends their life.

Are old shingles toxic to pets? The main risk is physical: sharp edges can cut paws, and loose granules are not good to ingest. Keep pets off freshly laid shingles until they are secured and covered, and sweep up any loose granules.

Can I burn old shingles to get rid of them? Never. Burning asphalt shingles releases toxic fumes and is illegal in many places. Reuse them in the garden as described, or check with your local waste facility for proper disposal.

Do I need to seal or paint old shingles before using them? No. Sealing or painting them is unnecessary and can trap moisture or create a slippery surface. Use them as they are.

Using Old Shingles in the Garden: A Practical Guide

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to top