This guide walks you through a simple, controlled experiment to observe how detergent in water affects plant growth. You’ll grow identical plants in plain water and in water mixed with a small amount of liquid dish soap, then compare their health over a couple of weeks. This is a great way to see firsthand how pollutants and chemicals can impact living things. Before you start, gather your materials and choose a consistent spot where your plants will get the same light and temperature.
What You’ll Need
- Six small pots (or paper cups with drainage holes poked in the bottom)
- Potting soil
- Fast-growing seeds (e.g., bean, pea, or radish seeds)
- Liquid dish soap (a plain, clear type works best)
- Two clean watering containers or spray bottles
- Measuring spoon (teaspoon)
- Ruler
- Notebook and pen for observations
- Labels or tape
Step-by-Step
- Prepare the pots. Fill all six pots with the same amount of potting soil. Gently firm the soil down, but don’t pack it too tightly. Label three pots as “Control” and three as “Detergent.”
- Plant the seeds. Plant two seeds in each pot, about half an inch deep. Cover them lightly with soil. Water all pots with plain water until the soil is moist but not soggy.
- Create the detergent solution. In one of your watering containers, mix one teaspoon of liquid dish soap into one quart of water. Stir gently to combine. This is a very dilute solution, similar to what might be found in wastewater after cleaning.
- Set up the watering schedule. You’ll water the Control pots with plain water and the Detergent pots with the soapy water. Use the same amount for each pot—enough to keep the soil moist but not flooded. Water every two to three days, or whenever the top of the soil feels dry.
- Place the pots in a consistent location. Put all six pots in a spot that gets bright, indirect sunlight for most of the day. A windowsill or a table near a window works well. Rotate the pots a quarter turn each day to ensure even light exposure.
- Observe and measure daily. Starting when the seeds sprout, check the plants each day. Measure the height of each plant with a ruler, counting from the soil line to the top of the tallest stem. Record the height in your notebook. Also note the color of the leaves, any wilting, or spots.
- Continue for two to three weeks. Keep up the same watering and measuring routine. Be consistent—this is key to a fair test. The only difference between the two groups should be the detergent in the water.
- Compare your results. At the end of the experiment, average the heights of the Control plants and the Detergent plants. Compare the averages, and also look at the overall health: leaf color, number of leaves, and any signs of stress.
- Draw conclusions. Based on your data, did the detergent affect plant growth? Did the plants in soapy water grow less, look yellow, or wilt faster? Write down your conclusion and what you think it means about detergents in the environment.
Common Mistakes
- Using too much detergent. A single teaspoon per quart is already a strong concentration for a plant. More soap will likely kill the plants quickly, making it hard to observe subtle effects.
- Inconsistent watering. Giving one pot more water than another, or letting some pots dry out completely, will skew your results. Always use the same amount and frequency.
- Not controlling other variables. If some pots get more sun or are in a draft, that affects growth. Keep all conditions identical except for the detergent.
- Starting with unhealthy seeds. If seeds don’t sprout, you can’t compare growth. Use fresh seeds and plant a couple extra in each pot to ensure at least one sprouts.
- Measuring from the pot rim. Always measure from the soil surface, not the pot edge, or your numbers will be inconsistent.
Tips
- Use a clear, fragrance-free dish soap. Dyes and perfumes can add extra chemicals that might affect the experiment in ways you’re not testing.
- Take photos each day. Visual records help you see changes that numbers might miss, like yellowing or leaf curl.
- If you want to test different concentrations, set up more than two groups—for example, a control, a low-detergent group, and a high-detergent group. Just make sure each group has at least three pots for reliability.
- Wear gloves when handling the detergent solution, and wash your hands after watering. It’s not toxic at this dilution, but it’s good practice.
- Dispose of the soapy water down the drain, not on the garden, to avoid harming outdoor plants or soil microbes.
Troubleshooting
- Seeds don’t sprout. This can happen if the soil is too cold, too wet, or the seeds are old. Try again with fresh seeds, keep the soil consistently moist (not soaked), and place the pots in a warmer spot (around room temperature).
- All plants die. If even the control plants die, the issue is likely not the detergent. Check for overwatering, lack of drainage, or a disease. Make sure your pots have holes and you’re not drowning the roots.
- Detergent plants grow just as well as control. This can happen if the concentration is too low. Try increasing the detergent to two teaspoons per quart in a new round, or check that you’re actually mixing the soap thoroughly.
- Mold appears on the soil. This is usually from overwatering or poor air circulation. Let the soil dry out a bit more between waterings, and move the pots to a spot with better airflow (but not a draft).
- Leaves turn brown and crispy. This could be from the detergent burning the leaves if the solution splashes on them. Water carefully at the soil level, and if you see splash marks, wipe the leaves gently with a damp cloth.
- Your measurements are all over the place. If plant heights vary wildly within the same group, you may have uneven soil or light. Ensure each pot has the same amount of soil and is rotated daily.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is this experiment safe for kids to do?
Yes, with adult supervision. The detergent solution is very dilute, but it can irritate eyes and skin. Wear gloves and wash hands after handling.
Q: Can I use laundry detergent instead of dish soap?
You can, but laundry detergents often contain more additives like bleaches and enzymes, which can make the results more dramatic but less about the basic detergent effect. Dish soap is simpler and more predictable.
Q: How long should I run the experiment?
Two to three weeks is usually enough to see clear differences. If you want to see long-term effects, you could run it for a month, but you’ll need to repot if the plants get too big.
Q: What if my detergent plants actually grow better?
That’s possible if the soap contains nutrients like phosphates (though many are now phosphate-free). It’s a good reminder that the effect depends on the specific detergent and concentration. Note your observations and consider testing a different brand.
Q: Can I use a different type of plant?
Yes, but choose a fast-growing, hardy plant. Beans, peas, and radishes are excellent choices because they sprout quickly and show visible responses. Avoid slow-growing plants like cacti.
Q: What does this experiment tell us about real-world pollution?
It demonstrates that even small amounts of common household chemicals can stress plants. In the environment, detergent pollution can come from greywater or spills, and this experiment shows a simplified version of that impact. However, real-world soil and water systems are more complex, so results may vary.