Choosing between a pothos and an ivy can be confusing because both are popular, trailing houseplants with similar-looking leaves. However, they belong to different plant families, have different care needs, and behave very differently in your home. This guide will help you tell them apart, choose the right one for your space, and care for whichever you pick.
What You’ll Need
- A healthy specimen of the plant you want to identify (or clear photos of the leaves, stems, and growth habit)
- Optional: a magnifying glass to examine leaf details
- For care: a pot with drainage holes, well-draining potting mix, and a watering can
Step-by-Step
- Look at the leaf shape. Pothos leaves are heart-shaped, thick, and waxy, with a slightly curved, almost succulent feel. Ivy leaves are typically lobed (like a star or with three to five points), thinner, and more delicate. If the leaf has deep indentations or points, it’s likely an ivy; if it’s a smooth, solid heart, it’s a pothos.
- Check the leaf texture. Run your fingers over the leaf. Pothos leaves feel leathery and glossy, even in low light. Ivy leaves feel thinner and matte, often with a slightly rough or hairy texture depending on the variety.
- Examine the stem. Pothos stems are thick, green, and slightly grooved, with aerial roots at each node that help it climb. Ivy stems are thinner, often woody at the base, and may have tiny rootlets along the stem that cling to surfaces like brick or bark.
- Observe the growth pattern. Pothos tends to trail or climb with long, single vines that can reach several feet. Ivy also trails or climbs, but it branches more readily, creating a bushier, denser look. Ivy’s clinging roots allow it to scale walls, while pothos needs support to climb and will otherwise cascade.
- Look at the leaf color and variegation. Pothos commonly has green leaves with yellow, white, or golden variegation (like the classic golden pothos). Ivy also has variegated varieties, but the pattern is often more speckled or edged, and the green is usually darker and richer.
- Check the roots if possible. If you can gently slide the plant out of its pot, pothos roots are thick and white, while ivy roots are finer and more wiry. This is a definitive test but only do it if the plant is dry and you can handle it gently.
- Consider the growth rate. Pothos grows faster and is more forgiving of neglect. Ivy grows more slowly and is more sensitive to overwatering and hot, dry air. If you need a quick, easy filler, choose pothos; if you want a classic, structured climber, choose ivy.
- Think about your light. Pothos tolerates low light well and thrives in bright, indirect light. Ivy prefers cooler temperatures and bright, indirect light but can struggle in very dark corners. If your room is dim, pothos is the safer bet.
- Decide based on your pets. Both plants are toxic to cats and dogs if ingested, so if you have curious pets, you may want to choose a non-toxic alternative or place the plant well out of reach.
Common Mistakes
- Mistaking a young ivy for a pothos. Some ivy varieties have un-lobed juvenile leaves that look similar to pothos. Check the stem and texture; ivy stems are thinner and leaves are less waxy.
- Overwatering both. Both plants dislike soggy soil. Overwatering is the number one killer of both pothos and ivy. Always let the top inch of soil dry out before watering again.
- Placing ivy in a hot, dry spot. Ivy prefers cooler, more humid conditions. Near a radiator or in a dry, air-conditioned room, ivy will develop crispy leaves and spider mites. Pothos is more tolerant of average home humidity.
- Assuming both need the same soil. Pothos is fine in a standard all-purpose potting mix. Ivy prefers a slightly grittier, well-draining mix with some perlite or sand to prevent root rot.
- Not pruning. Both plants benefit from occasional pruning to stay full. If you let them grow unchecked, they can become leggy and sparse.
Tips
- For a quick visual test, remember: pothos leaves are hearts, ivy leaves are stars.
- If you want a trailing plant for a shelf, pothos is easier and more forgiving.
- If you want a plant to climb a moss pole or trellis, both work, but ivy will cling on its own; pothos will need gentle ties to guide it.
- To encourage fuller growth, pinch off the growing tips regularly. This works for both plants.
- Clean the leaves occasionally with a damp cloth to keep them photosynthesizing well, especially if you have dusty rooms.
- When in doubt, check the botanical name on the plant tag: pothos is Epipremnum aureum, while ivy is usually Hedera helix (English ivy) or a related species.
Troubleshooting
- My plant has yellow leaves. This is usually overwatering for both. Let the soil dry out more between waterings. If the yellow leaves are at the base and the plant is otherwise healthy, it might just be old age—remove them.
- My ivy has brown, crispy leaf edges. This is often low humidity or too much direct sun. Move it to a brighter spot with indirect light and increase humidity with a pebble tray or a nearby humidifier.
- My pothos has brown spots on the leaves. This could be sunburn if it’s in direct sun, or a sign of a fungal issue from wet leaves. Move it to indirect light and avoid splashing water on the foliage.
- My plant is growing leggy and sparse. Both plants need more light. Move them to a brighter location, but avoid harsh direct sun, which can scorch leaves. Prune back the leggy stems to encourage bushier growth.
- My ivy has webbing and tiny dots on the undersides of leaves. That’s spider mites, which love dry, warm air. Rinse the plant in the shower or wipe leaves with a damp cloth, and increase humidity. Isolate the plant to prevent spread.
- My pothos is dropping leaves. This can be from a sudden change in temperature or draft, or from root rot due to overwatering. Check the roots—if they’re mushy and dark, cut away the rotted parts and repot in fresh, dry soil.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Can I grow pothos and ivy together in the same pot? Yes, you can, but they have slightly different care needs. Pothos is more drought-tolerant, while ivy prefers more moisture. You’ll need to water to the ivy’s needs and ensure the pothos doesn’t get too waterlogged. It’s easier to keep them separate.
- Which plant is better for a bathroom? Both can work if the bathroom has a window. Ivy loves the humidity, but pothos is more forgiving of lower light. If your bathroom is dark, choose pothos.
- Are pothos and ivy the same plant? No. Pothos is in the arum family (Araceae), while ivy is in the ginseng family (Araliaceae). They are not closely related, despite similar appearances.
- How often should I water my pothos or ivy? There’s no set schedule. Check the soil: water when the top inch feels dry. Pothos can go a bit longer between waterings than ivy. In winter, both need less water.
- Is it safe to keep these plants around pets? Both are toxic to cats and dogs if ingested, causing mouth irritation and digestive upset. If you have pets, consider a non-toxic alternative like a spider plant or a Boston fern.
- Can I propagate both plants from cuttings? Yes, both are easy to propagate. Take a cutting with a few leaves, remove the lower leaves, and place the stem in water or moist soil. Roots should develop within a few weeks.
Pothos vs Ivy: Key Differences & Care Guide